Heartland 2019: Syndrome K

Syndrome K has a compelling story to tell, but the way it goes about it dilutes this documentary’s impact.

This Italian feature relates the story of how three doctors working in a Roman Catholic hospital run by the Vatican created a fake disease as a ploy to save as many of Rome’s Jewish population as possible. The fake ailment was described as a “highly contagious, highly fatal … disease, most commonly found in Romans of Jewish descent.”

The film, which mostly covers events from 1943 through the Allied liberation of Rome in 1944, centers not so much on Syndrome K itself but on the doctors who created it, their relationship with the Vatican and the various ploys used by the medical staff to rescue Jews from the clutches of the Nazi SS after the German Army took control of the city.

The manner in which the documentary is put together undercuts its potential. Recreations and scenes from post-World War II, neorealistic Italian films such as Open City are mixed with archival footage and talking heads to explain events in Rome during the war and occupation. This soon becomes a distraction, especially in a film that is a mere 72 minutes and repeats some of the same footage.

It is the old survivors — and children of others involved — who carry the movie. They do more than extol the courage of their fathers and others but also put the status of Rome’s Jews and the Vatican’s position during the war into context.

Pope Pius XII has been criticized for keeping silent about Germany’s genocide of European Jewry. But, as some survivors point out, Pius, who beside being the spiritual leader of the Roman Catholic Church, also was the political leader of a sovereign nation — the Vatican. He had to maintain a delicate balance, realizing that if he publicly rebuked Adolf Hitler, it would put the Vatican in jeopardy. According to some interviewed for the movie, Pius made private pleas to the German government about showing mercy to Jews, especially those who live in Rome. But his messages were ignored.

But while the pope did not act, others did. Doctors at the Fatebenefratelli Hospital, which was built on Vatican property and thus was overseen by the papacy, were the ones who created Syndrome K. They also quietly — and without Vatican approval — helped the resistance in Rome. Jews who came to the hospital were “diagnosed” with the illness and given hospital beds. After a few weeks, they were funneled to churches, monasteries and convents around Rome where they were given sanctuary until the liberation.

What is most interesting about Syndrome K is that members of the SS, including officers and the group’s own doctors, were hoodwinked. Even when they raided the hospital, they did not go far into the isolation ward housing “patients” with the illness. It turns out, one of the phobias of a vast majority of these “elite” SS units, was coming into contact with sick patients.

The number of Jews saved by these humanitarians was relatively small in the overall context of the murder of six million people. But even the saving of one life is a blessing that should be cherished.

Syndrome K offers inspiration, but its power is offset by the sloppy manner in which it presented. I appreciate eyewitness accounts and the use of archival film, but going beyond that negates some of the documentary’s muscle.

______________________________________________________________________________

Syndrome K is an Indiana Spotlight finalist at the 2019 Heartland Film Festival. Tickets can be purchased here.

SHOWTIMES

7:10 p.m., Monday, Oct. 14 — AMC Castleton Square Theater 2
12:30 p.m.., Friday, Oct. 18 — AMC Castleton Square Theater 9



Avatar
About

Bob Bloom is a founding member of the Indiana Film Journalists Association. His reviews appear at ReelBob and Rotten Tomatoes. He also Blu-rays and DVDs. He can be reached by email at bobbloomjc@gmail.com or on Twitter @ReelBobBloom. Links to his reviews can be found on Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn.


%d bloggers like this: